Falconi wrote:Greyaxe wrote:You missed my point; backups are not separate entities but part of a whole, like your arm. Each taking turn at dominance is not a question of which artificial intelligence is in control but which part of my body is in control at this moment. Human psychology could be compared as thinking with your ***** when attempting to woo a person of interest. It is that portion of your brain in conjunction with the hardware necessary to facilitate that effort is the dominant area for a time. The next morning your legs and fear portion of the brain may be in control if you realize this encounter was a mistake. So it’s not a reasonable comparison to suggest that Archie’s backups are separate from him but are rather part of a whole. The only way your theory may actually happen is if one of these backups were severed and forgotten ages ago, or was believed to be completely destroyed, and for whatever reason would be awakened some time later. You would have two completely different A.R.C.H.I.E. units, one a megalomaniac and one functioning more or less under its base programming (as it has not been active for a long time).
I'm not sure I completely agree here.. By definition a backup is a facsimile of an original to be used in the case where the original becomes unusable. So to continue with your example, it would be more like a person who was cloned. They are a direct copy of the original. You can't control the legs or the libido of your clone. Granted its a little different than something biological because we're talking about a computer that can be completely erased and then restored to its previous state (Certainly something that can't be done to a human being). That being said, ARCHIE would certainly have access to the backup unless as you suggest, the connection was somehow severed. Access means also that he has the capacity to destroy that backup too..
Well: if we are going to get into a discussion of what a backup is lets clarify what we are talking about.
Wyrmbear wrote:ARCHIE's got backups of himself -- he must, as paranoid as he is.
So somewhere out there must be a full, dormant ARCHIE system.
ARCHIE's already shown signs of mental illness, including paranoia, megalomania, and so on.
Now comes the theoretical part.
What if a BACKUP were awakened before the destruction of the "original" ARCHIE?
The megalomaniacal trait wouldn't allow both to exist together.
The enhanced paranoia and megalomania possible via the self-awareness of its status as just a backup could make ARCHIE-3b even more dangerous, but its focus would most likely be on the destruction of the Alpha. Though there is the possibility of AI-suicide.
Replica: Live copy of an original or master server updated usually in real time for redundancy and load sharing. Typically using failover protocols to change the master/slave relationship as required.( my interprited view of the posters theory)
Backup: Two Types
1. Online backup, meaning live and attached over a functional network to a storage device for immediate restore of original code or data. Typically not used on Live operating systems but useful for application restores and data recovery
2. Offline Backup formerly referred to Tape Backup. A copy of all code including operating system stored magnetically onto tape, optical disk or fixed disk, often in a remote or offsite location for security and redundancy. This type of backup is applied for full system restore of OS and applications as well as raw data. Requires third party (human) intervention to restore.
As stated initially it is a Full Live Backup; which I translated to replica as it would require real-time updates and no intervention to restore, which I believe is the spirit of the situation. One of these replicas breaks away form the whole to become a fully functional entity, independent of the original. Unfortunately it would be Identical to the original; how it would interpret the situation is anyone’s guess.
Here re my suggestions:
1. Archie the broken replica realizes it’s a part of a whole and tries to reestablish connection.
2. Archie’s, megalomania and paranoia supersedes computer logic and decided to live on its own. Strong possibility of dissention as Original Archie and Replica Archie are aware of each other secret locations and would in the interest of self preservation start a robot war.
3. Original Archie and Replica Archie now begin to develop separately of one another and realize they are or will become separate entities capable of argument and between them creative thinking. They unite and end the eternal loneliness’. Next step self preservation, a war on biologics in the area begins to create a buffer zone of safety. Beginnings of NWO as machines can now truly begin to replicate and propagate equals.