Thank you One Hand Clapping and Akashic Soldier for your praise, It was an awesome book to write. While I know you can't please everyone here are a few points that might shed some light on your issues and rekindle your interest.
Rappanui wrote: Finally getting to read Lemuria a few things dissapoint me.
1. The setting is almost entirely along the region of the indian ocean.
The Lemurians once dominated the Indian Ocean like the Atlanteans dominated the Atlantic Ocean. The eventually spread their Polynesian influence along the Pacific Rim into the Pacific. As such they always consider the Indian Ocean their "home".
While I wrote a ton of other stuff for the Pacific Rim and Pacific Ocean, Kevin asked me to cut it out to make the Lemuria Book just about the Lemurians. You should be happy to know that that material is finished and going through a final edit to become the New Navy book by my buddy and I hope to have it to Kevin in a month or so. It contains a whole ton of world info on the Pacific Rim and Pacific Ocean, including undersea colonies, re-colonization efforts to retake the Pacific Rim and islands, New Navy equipment, New Navy spies and information gathering O.C.C.s as well as adventures and how to get "Land Lubber" Characters into an Undersea campaign and in a position to find and use the cool toys in this book as well as stuff in Rifts Lemuria...
2. The Mdc weapons are lackluster, almost no threat to anything from atlantis.
True, their has been a consist reeling in of damage levels in newer books. But what you may have missed is that "ALL" Lemurian weapons, including the physical attacks of their Bio-Armor does double damage to vampires and the undead as it is a product of Biomancy!
3. If it wasn't for the Malanui i'd have almost no use for the book at all. The OCCs/Rccs are rather restricted and very little odds of non lemurians ever learning them.
Can't really argue with that, but since it is a book on Lemurians I'd think most people would want O.C.C.s specifically for them? Having said that the Spouter is a Psychic O.C.C. which can be taken by anyone and while it has "Hydro-Psionics" it is just the same as a Burster who has 7 sub-Pyrokinetic Powers, only you get to pick and chose which powers you want with the Spouter and eventually get way more than the Burster.
4. The confusion between mounts and monsters ...? They are all blended together... if it wasn't for the illustrations i wouldn't know it was a mount.
As was stated by another poster they ride Monsters, so of course their mounts are going to be monstrous.
5. Why is there Panther shark ... but then a Tiger Serpent?
You can blame Chuck on that one
In all seriousness the Tiger Serpent was originally supposed to be more snake like with tiger stripe patterning, but when someone like Chuck puts pencil to paper and produces an awesome piece like he did you have to go with the flow
As fort the Panther Shark that was another of Chuck’s awesome drawings, but their where no stats for it so it actually inspired the monster. Now if I catch your subtle feline interjection, the Tiger Serpent is a feline serpent, where as the Panther Shark is a feline quadruped shark creature, its not like we did a Panther Serpent and a Tiger Serpent.
6. New Dragons.. ok.. but why conflicting names .. Hydros? Ghost?... Why is there a sand dragon?
Didn't see any reason why there are so many new aquatic dragons....
Is there some missing article about Dragons that were supposed to be lemurian allies from Back BEfore the rifts came?
How are the names conflicting? Hydros as in
Hyrdo - Latin for water and Ghost, well it eats ghosts and has ghost like powers? As for them being dragons, they are another species of "Serpent" that the Serpent Hunters can tame and ride if one is bold enough to try and take one down...
As for the Sand Dragon I thought the idea was really cool, a dragon who build sand castles!
, but I guess you can complain as you didn't like them and have a different opinion.