Page 1 of 1

Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 12:38 am
by Hadeshorn
So for our next campaign, my group and I will be playing various Martial Artists from China/Japan who get rifted to Mexico. I will be playing a Jeridu (6 armed Elf like dudes from Fantasy) Blind Mystic. I'd originally planned on taking the White Jade Fan as my basic Martial Art style because the idea of being a six armed blind dude who kicks butt with fans just sounds awesome. The only downside is they get gimped on attacks per melee hard, 2 vs the standard 4. Yes, some of that will be offset by my Jeridu-ness but its still rough, especially in a smaller group.

TL;DR - Can anyone think of any other "cool" HtH Martial Art styles that might fit? I've looked through China 2, Japan, Mystic China and a decent chunk of the Rifters.

At the end of the day, I may just end up asking my GM to amend the attacks if I can't find something else that fits.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 4:07 am
by Blue_Lion
Ninjas and Superspies has allot of martial arts.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 7:21 am
by narcissus
Japan and China 2 were published before RUE and the "2 attacks for breathing" rule, so as a GM I'd bump that to 4.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 9:29 am
by ShadowLogan
narcissus wrote:Japan and China 2 were published before RUE and the "2 attacks for breathing" rule, so as a GM I'd bump that to 4.

This.

I'm not sure if China 2 came out before RUE off hand (I don't have that book), but I know Japan did. Back in the RMB days the 2 for living was noted in the main book in an odd place (it might even be in PF2E's main book), and you where expected to add it in I think.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 1:28 pm
by Blue_Lion
narcissus wrote:Japan and China 2 were published before RUE and the "2 attacks for breathing" rule, so as a GM I'd bump that to 4.

You seam to mixing things up. The two attacks for breathing was from pre-GMG where you had to manually add them in. It showed up early in rifts so they are not before the rule existed. I know Japans martial arts got redone with the attacks baked in to them in the GMG. To know if you need to apply the 2 attacks for breathing you have to see if the other marital arts have them baked in. (The GM guide has them baked in in some of the exotic marital arts.)

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 6:12 pm
by Curbludgeon
I'd argue the level 6 ability of the form found in WB25 was intended as something other than W.P. Paired. The versions from N&SS/MC (which save slightly different ability/power access are identical) have similar APM to other forms in those books, so it's possible there was a tradeoff intended in the adaptation. WB25's Falling Fan Trick could also stand some clarification.

Rather than try to fix the Rifts form I'd say use another. If Eighteen Weapons on a six armed dude is too close to Hindu iconography for your taste you might consider lifting Moo Gi Gong from N&SS, with or without Hwarang-Do, and play as someone throwing everything not nailed down.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 7:15 pm
by narcissus
Blue_Lion wrote:
narcissus wrote:Japan and China 2 were published before RUE and the "2 attacks for breathing" rule, so as a GM I'd bump that to 4.

You seam to mixing things up. The two attacks for breathing was from pre-GMG where you had to manually add them in. It showed up early in rifts so they are not before the rule existed. I know Japans martial arts got redone with the attacks baked in to them in the GMG. To know if you need to apply the 2 attacks for breathing you have to see if the other marital arts have them baked in. (The GM guide has them baked in in some of the exotic marital arts.)


I stand corrected. Other forms in China 2 have more than 2 attacks, so it looks like White Jade Fan legitimately starts with only 2 attacks.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 17, 2021 10:16 pm
by drewkitty ~..~
I would point out that any Martial Arts H2H skills from RChina2 (or if importing Martial Art Forms from N&S and MC.) they would have to be modified to fix your planed leaf ear character. The MAFs would have to be modified extensively because of the leaf ear's six arms that each can used in each attack wouldn't fit with the two armed forms of the N&S and MC MAF's.

I think there was a Rahu Man rifter article...not sure if they contained a h2h for them. But, if it did, you could use that as a guild to how to mod the RC2 martial arts h2hs.

With the MAF's...it is harder to figure out the modifications. Better to write out a whole MAF just for use of the 6armed leaf ear.

Number of APM...remember that most of the RC2 MA H2H's are learned in mundane-mystic pairs and added things together.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Sat Sep 18, 2021 12:39 am
by Hadeshorn
China 2 does specifically mention that they include the "2 for breathing." So yeah, Jade Fans is only 2 attacks, and if I weren't getting extra attacks from my RCC, I'd have those 2 attacks. Which would be alright, if I were like my humpback whale from Undersea where my 2 attacks.

I was hoping to keep it in the flavor of the Blind Mystic where they have "deceptive" martial art styles. I'll see if I can find a PDF of NaSS as our physical copy has, ironically, disappeared.

Oh, and I did look at the Rahu Man HtH a bit. But I think it also relies on their extra size as well.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Fri Sep 24, 2021 11:39 pm
by Curbludgeon
As hand to hands go Rifts Drunken Style, with its continuous automatic dodge explicitly at full dodge bonus, is hard to beat, especially when paired with a species which grants an (unfortunately ambiguously worded) amount of bonus attacks per melee. One could make an argument that since China 2 was published before RUE that the earlier book isn't compliant, and both a Jeridu's innate and RDB's trained automatic dodges are as-is unplayable in an RUE game. I'd offer in response to chill out, dork, and consider getting something from multiple sources sufficient impetus to rule of cool it.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Sat Sep 25, 2021 11:12 am
by Hotrod
Wormwood has a martial arts-like class: the monk. There's also the Warrior Monk O.C.C. in Palladium Fantasy.

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Sat Sep 25, 2021 1:19 pm
by ShadowLogan
Hotrod wrote:Wormwood has a martial arts-like class: the monk. There's also the Warrior Monk O.C.C. in Palladium Fantasy.

In terms of Monks, (WB8) Japan has a few (Sohei Warrior Monk and Bishamon Fighting Monk)

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Tue Sep 28, 2021 11:13 pm
by Hell knight
You can all so find martial arts in rifter 7 and 3 and mystic china .

Re: Need Martial Art/Hand to Hand Help

Posted: Wed Dec 08, 2021 1:04 pm
by EliBenedict
You can back-door you original concept in the RAW using Zanji. Your attacks per round and strike bonuses will out perform any RUE hand to jand style. At 3rd level, you could take WP-Fan as a specialty kata, and then at 7th you could take WP paired-Fan, completing your transformation into a whirling church-lady of death.